StockFetcher Forums · General Discussion · Guppy Investor Line<< >>Post Follow-up
sammyn
81 posts
msg #145262
- Ignore sammyn
modified		 11/14/2018 8:13:30 AM

throwing this out there for discussion.

So, thinking about the investor band. What if we weighted the averages of the EMAs (60 has more weight than the 30).

Then, plotted the closing price against that weighted average. I'm sure this isn't earth shattering, just a different way at looking at the investor average.


Fetcher[apply to symlist(spy,qqq,iwm,gld,gdx,vxx)

/*INVESTOR GROUP*/
draw EMA(30)
draw EMA(35)
draw EMA(40)
draw EMA(45)
draw EMA(50)
draw EMA(60)

set{x30, EMA(30) * .115}
set{x35, EMA(35) * .135}
set{x40, EMA(40) * .154}
set{x45, EMA(45) * .173}
set{x50, EMA(50) * .192}
set{x60, EMA(60) * .231}
set{s3, x30 + x35}
set{s4, x40 + x45}
set{s5, x50 + x60}
set{s6, s3 + s4}
set{investor, s5 + s6}
set{invDiff, close - investor}
set{invDiffPct, invDiff / close}

set{closeAbove, count(invDiffPct > 0, 1)}
draw closeAbove

draw invDiffPct line at 0
]



Thought? Comments? Opinions?
sammyn
81 posts
msg #145263
- Ignore sammyn		 11/14/2018 8:59:24 AM

hmmm...another version

basically, plot the trader MA ave on the Investor MA ave. Also include the bar chart of the closing prices above those MA averages.

Fetcher[apply to symlist(spy,qqq,iwm,gld,gdx,vxx)

/*TRADER GROUP*/
draw EMA(3)
draw EMA(5)
draw EMA(8)
draw EMA(10)
draw EMA(12)
draw EMA(15)

set{x3, EMA(3) * .057}
set{x5, EMA(5) * .094}
set{x8, EMA(8) * .151}
set{x10, EMA(10) * .189}
set{x12, EMA(12) * .226}
set{x15, EMA(15) * .283}

set{t3, x3 + x5}
set{t4, x8 + x10}
set{t5, x12 + x15}
set{t6, t3 + t4}

set{trader, t5 + t6}
set{traDiff, close - trader}
set{traDiffPct, traDiff / close}
set{closeAboveTra, count(traDiffPct > 0, 1)}



/*INVESTOR GROUP*/
draw EMA(30)
draw EMA(35)
draw EMA(40)
draw EMA(45)
draw EMA(50)
draw EMA(60)

set{x30, EMA(30) * .115}
set{x35, EMA(35) * .135}
set{x40, EMA(40) * .154}
set{x45, EMA(45) * .173}
set{x50, EMA(50) * .192}
set{x60, EMA(60) * .231}
set{s3, x30 + x35}
set{s4, x40 + x45}
set{s5, x50 + x60}
set{s6, s3 + s4}
set{investor, s5 + s6}
set{invDiff, close - investor}
set{invDiffPct, invDiff / close}
set{closeAboveInv, count(invDiffPct > 0, 1)}

/* draw plots */
draw closeAboveTra
draw closeAboveInv

draw investor
draw trader on plot investor

draw traDiffPct line at 0
draw invDiffPct line at 0


]
nibor100
1,045 posts
msg #145268
- Ignore nibor100		 11/14/2018 7:04:37 PM

I was surprised your weights weren't greater than 1 such as 1.115 for x30 and am curious as to how you came up with your weights for the short term and long term groups of averages?

The way EMAs are calculated the Guppy normal averages are already weighted in the opposite direction that you are weighting them, with a greater weight being applied to the lowest avg in each group.

Did you consider/try just plotting your newly calculated short term group vs the newly calculated long term group without the normal Guppy's on the chart?

Thanks,
Ed S.



sammyn
81 posts
msg #145269
- Ignore sammyn		 11/14/2018 8:04:00 PM

So, it sounds like Guppy does something like this already (since you are saying a shorter EMA should be weighted more). If so, I'm unaware of that. (If it's in his book, I'm still working my way through it). This idea just came to me, while trying to clean up the charts.

Can you point me in the right direction where I can read more about weighing the lower EMAs more?

How I came up with my weighting was:
30+35+40+45+50+60 = 260

30/260 = 0.115
35/260 = 0.135
40/260 = 0.154
45/260 = 0.173
50/260 = 0.192
60/260 = 0.231

[quote]
Did you consider/try just plotting your newly calculated short term group vs the newly calculated long term group without the normal Guppy's on the chart?
[/quote]
That's what those investor/trader lines are. But, here it is, without the rainbow chart:

Fetcher[apply to symlist(spy,qqq,iwm,gld,gdx,vxx)

set{x3, EMA(3) * .057}
set{x5, EMA(5) * .094}
set{x8, EMA(8) * .151}
set{x10, EMA(10) * .189}
set{x12, EMA(12) * .226}
set{x15, EMA(15) * .283}
set{t3, x3 + x5}
set{t4, x8 + x10}
set{t5, x12 + x15}
set{t6, t3 + t4}
set{trader, t5 + t6}
set{traDiff, close - trader}
set{traDiffPct, traDiff / close}
set{closeAboveTra, count(traDiffPct > 0, 1)}



set{x30, EMA(30) * .115}
set{x35, EMA(35) * .135}
set{x40, EMA(40) * .154}
set{x45, EMA(45) * .173}
set{x50, EMA(50) * .192}
set{x60, EMA(60) * .231}
set{s3, x30 + x35}
set{s4, x40 + x45}
set{s5, x50 + x60}
set{s6, s3 + s4}
set{investor, s5 + s6}
set{invDiff, close - investor}
set{invDiffPct, invDiff / close}
set{closeAboveInv, count(invDiffPct > 0, 1)}

draw investor on plot price
draw trader on plot price
]
nibor100
1,045 posts
msg #145274
- Ignore nibor100		 11/15/2018 10:30:48 AM

I beilieve I was a bit unclear in my prior post:

1. What I meant to convey is that the Exponential Moving Avg calculation used to compute each of the 12 Guppy moving averages weights the most recent closing price more than prior values whereas simple moving averages assign equal weight to all closing prices.

The following is from the Chart School website:

"The Weighting Multiplier
A 10-period exponential moving average applies an 18.18% weighting to the most recent price. A 10-period EMA can also be called an 18.18% EMA. A 20-period EMA applies a 9.52% weighting to the most recent price (2/(20+1) = .0952). Notice that the weighting for the shorter time period is more than the weighting for the longer time period. In fact, the weighting drops by half every time the moving average period doubles.

If you want to use a specific percentage for an EMA, you can use this formula to convert it to time periods and then enter that value as the EMA's parameter:
Time Period = (2 / Percentage) - 1
3% Example: Time Period = (2 / 0.03) - 1 = 65.67 time periods"

2. Regarding plotting your newly calculated short term and long term groups I was referring to the actual line calculations for the 12 individual lines and not your composite indicator line which I liked as it was.

Below is what I was asking about:

Fetcher[
apply to symlist(spy,qqq,iwm,gld,gdx,vxx)

set{x3, EMA(3) * .057}
set{x5, EMA(5) * .094}
set{x8, EMA(8) * .151}
set{x10, EMA(10) * .189}
set{x12, EMA(12) * .226}
set{x15, EMA(15) * .283}

draw x3 on plot price
draw x5 on plot price
draw x8 on plot price
draw x10 on plot price
draw x12 on plot price
draw x15 on plot price

set{t3, x3 + x5}
set{t4, x8 + x10}
set{t5, x12 + x15}
set{t6, t3 + t4}
set{trader, t5 + t6}
set{traDiff, close - trader}
set{traDiffPct, traDiff / close}
set{closeAboveTra, count(traDiffPct > 0, 1)}



set{x30, EMA(30) * .115}
set{x35, EMA(35) * .135}
set{x40, EMA(40) * .154}
set{x45, EMA(45) * .173}
set{x50, EMA(50) * .192}
set{x60, EMA(60) * .231}

draw x30 on plot price
draw x35 on plot price
draw x40 on plot price
draw x45 on plot price
draw x50 on plot price
draw x60 on plot price
set{s3, x30 + x35}
set{s4, x40 + x45}
set{s5, x50 + x60}
set{s6, s3 + s4}
set{investor, s5 + s6}
set{invDiff, close - investor}
set{invDiffPct, invDiff / close}
set{closeAboveInv, count(invDiffPct > 0, 1)}

draw closeAboveTra
draw closeAboveInv

draw investor
draw trader on plot investor

draw traDiffPct line at 0
draw invDiffPct line at 0

chart-time is 2 years
]



Thanks,
Ed S.
StockFetcher Forums · General Discussion · Guppy Investor Line<< >>Post Follow-up

StockFetcher Tools
Filter Editor
My Filters
Watch Lists
Chart+
Find Similar Stocks
Shared Lists
Popular Resources
StockFetcher Forums
Indicator List
Filter Phrases
Examples
Site Search
Sector/Industry List
Usage Guide
Support
Contact Us
Support Home

Subscriber
Subscriber Benefits
Settings
Chart
Results
MyFilters
*** Disclaimer *** StockFetcher.com does not endorse or suggest any of the securities which are returned in any of the searches or filters. They are provided purely for informational and research purposes. StockFetcher.com does not recommend particular securities. StockFetcher.com, Vestyl Software, L.L.C. and involved content providers shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken based on the content.


Copyright 2022 - Vestyl Software L.L.C.•Terms of Service | License | Questions or comments? Contact Us
EOD Data sources: DDFPlus & CSI Data Quotes delayed during active market hours. Delay times are at least 15 mins for NASDAQ, 20 mins for NYSE and Amex. Delayed intraday data provided by DDFPlus


This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.